ScienceDaily (Feb. 29, 2008) — New research from the University of Exeter in collaboration with the University of Texas at Austin published in the journal Science on February 22, 2008 questions claims that EU conservation policy has been successful in protecting endangered birds.

Introduced in 1979, the EU Birds Directive set out a plan to protect rare birds in all EU countries. A study by scientists from the RSPB and BirdLife International, published in Science in August 2007, argued that the policy had resulted in positive impacts on bird conservation, even saving species that were near extinction.*

This new research, however, reveals that the arguments presented in the recent study were flawed and based on inadequate data and predictions. By simply comparing bird populations inside and outside of the EU, the research did not take into account the fact that EU countries are generally wealthier and more developed than European countries outside the Union.

Additionally the evidence used to support EU policy included marine reserves in some countries, but ignored them in others. The Exeter researchers argue that this created the impression that the major EU policy for bird protection has been a success when in reality it may well have fallen short of its original aims.

The new research argues that conservation policies require systematic monitoring and evaluation if they are to be scientifically valid. "Current EU conservation policy can be likened to launching a rocket to Mars, but not actually bothering to check whether it gets there" said lead author Rolando Rodríguez-Muñoz of the University of Exeter.

"Without properly monitoring the efficacy of its policies, the EU risks wasting millions of pounds on ineffective conservation programmes." He commented further: "The Birds and Habitats Directives have become the keystones of the EU conservation policies. They are potentially powerful tools to protect our environment, but for these efforts to be efficient we need feedback to allow us to adapt to new situations or to correct poor implementation.

*See http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/08/070810074554.htm.

Related Stories

Bird Directive Has Helped 23 Threatened Species Recover (Aug. 11, 2007) — In the first scientific analysis of its kind anywhere in the world, the RSPB has shown that one example of protecting birds at a continental scale has improved the fortunes of the most threatened and ...  > read more

University Of Arkansas Researchers Create Computerized Map Of Latin America’s Threatened Birds (Apr. 27, 2000) — A first-of-its kind computerized map showing the ranges of threatened bird species in Latin America may help save these birds from ...  > read more

Global Map Shows New Patterns Of Extinction Risk (Nov. 5, 2006) — The most detailed world map of mammals, birds and amphibians ever produced shows that endangered species from these groups do not inhabit the same geographical areas, says new ...  > read more

Complete 'Family Tree' Of All British Birds Gives Clues About Which Species Might Be Endangered Next (June 17, 2008) — A new complete evolutionary 'family tree' showing how all British bird species are related to each other may provide clues about which ones are at risk of population decline. The greenfinch and the ...  > read more

Search ScienceDaily

Chickens On A Diet