ScienceDaily (June 22, 2009) — Are the cognitively superior brains of humans, in part, responsible for our higher rates of cancer? That's a question that has nagged at John McDonald, chair of Georgia Tech's School of Biology and chief research scientist at the Ovarian Cancer Institute, for a while. Now, after an initial study, it seems that McDonald is on to something. The new study is available online in the journal Medical Hypothesis and will appear in the forthcoming issue of the journal.

"I was always intrigued by the fact that chimpanzees appear to have lower rates of cancer than humans," said McDonald. "So we went back and reanalyzed some previously reported gene expression studies including data that were not used in the original analyses."

McDonald and his graduate students, Gaurav Arora and Nalini Polivarapu, compared chimp-human gene expression patterns in five tissues: brain, testes, liver, kidneys and heart. They found distinct differences in the way apoptosis — or programmed cell death — operates, suggesting that humans do not "self-destroy" cells as effectively as chimpanzees do. Apoptosis is one of the primary mechanisms by which our bodies destroy cancer cells.

"The results from our analysis suggest that humans aren't as efficient as chimpanzees in carrying out programmed cell death. We believe this difference may have evolved as a way to increase brain size and associated cognitive ability in humans, but the cost could be an increased propensity for cancer," said McDonald.

Like all evolutionary hypotheses, this can't be proven absolutely, according to McDonald. However, his lab has recently obtained additional direct experimental evidence consistent with the hypothesis that apoptotic function is more efficient in chimps than in humans.

Journal reference:

1. Gaurav Arora, Nalini Polavarapu, John F. McDonald. Did natural selection for increased cognitive ability in humans lead to an elevated risk of cancer? Medical Hypotheses, 2009; DOI: 10.1016/j.mehy.2009.03.035

enlarge

A new study suggests that humans cognitively superior brains means more instances of cancer compared to chimpanzees. (Credit: iStockphoto/Neal McClimon)

Related Stories

Young Chimps Top Adult Humans In Numerical Memory (Dec. 9, 2007) — Young chimpanzees have an "extraordinary" ability to remember numerals that is superior to that of human adults, researchers report. The researchers said they believe that the young chimps' newfound ...  > read more

Who's Bad? Chimps Figure It Out By Observation (Mar. 31, 2008) — Chimpanzees make judgments about the actions and dispositions of strangers by observing others' behavior and interactions in different situations. Specifically, chimpanzees show an ability to ...  > read more

Protein Stops P53 In Its Tracks In Cancer Cells (Feb. 21, 2007) — Overexpression of a protein known as HMGA1 has been associated with many types of cancer in humans. Previous studies have shown that HMGA1 decreases the ability of p53 to inhibit cell death by a ...  > read more

Humans And Chimps Register Faces By Using Similar Brain Regions (Dec. 27, 2008) — Chimpanzees recognize their pals by using some of the same brain regions that switch on when humans register a familiar face. The study -- the first to examine brain activity in chimpanzees after ...  > read more

Search ScienceDaily

Sea Urchins Reveal Medical Mysteries