Featured Research

from universities, journals, and other organizations

Two Leading Researchers Take Issue With Three Recent Studies On The Effects Of Genetically Engineered Crops

Date:
September 13, 1999
Source:
Cornell University
Summary:
Two prominent entomologists, one from Cornell University, warn that three recent studies on the effects of genetically engineered crops have distorted the debate about engineered crops and that this could have "profound consequences" for science and public policy.

ITHACA, N.Y. -- Two prominent entomologists, one from Cornell University, warn that three recent studies on the effects of genetically engineered crops have distorted the debate about engineered crops and that this could have "profound consequences" for science and public policy.

The article, "False reports and the ears of men," in the latest issue of Nature Biotechnology, is authored by Anthony M. Shelton, professor of entomology at Cornell's New York State College of Agriculture and Life Sciences, and Richard T. Roush of the University of Adelaide, Australia. They urge that the public should not be swayed "by laboratory reports that, when looked at with a critical eye, may not have any reality in the field or even in the laboratory."

The first of the three studies they comment on was led by John E. Losey, Cornell assistant professor of entomology. This study of the effect of Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) corn on the monarch butterfly "can only be considered a preliminary laboratory study," they write.

In the May 20 issue of Nature, Losey and his colleagues reported that pollen from commercial corn, genetically engineered to produce a bacterial toxin to protect it against European corn borers, kills monarch butterfly larvae in laboratory tests. While Shelton and Roush note that this result was expected under such laboratory test conditions, they question whether this test was realistic.

"If I went to a movie and bought a hundred pounds of salted popcorn, because I like salted popcorn, and then I ate those the salted popcorn all at once, I'd probably die. Eating that much salted popcorn simply is not a real-world situation, but if I died it may be reported that salted popcorn was lethal," Shelton said in an interview. "The same thing holds true for monarch butterflies and pollen. Scientists have a duty to be incredibly responsible for developing realistic studies. Scientists need to make assessments that are pertinent to the real world."

In the second study discussed in the article, researchers at Kansas State University reported in Science that they had discovered corn borer resistance to Bt toxins. Shelton and Roush question the methodology used in the study, "including that the authors did not demonstrate that resistance was actually to the same Bt toxin as in the plant or that the insects could survive on the Bt plant." Even so, they write, "this questionable laboratory study has generated considerable debate over whether the present resistance management policy should be overturned."

In another recent issue of Nature, a University of Arizona study showed that the pink bollworm's resistance to Bt-cotton was recessive in inheritance, but the paper questioned whether resistant bollworms developed more slowly than susceptible bollworms. This could possibly knock out random mating and dilute the insect's resistance in the field. "We hope that the take-home message won't be converted to another premature claim that Bt crops are doomed," Shelton and Roush say in their commentary.

Since the release of the monarch butterfly study, write Shelton and Roush, companies that make the genetically engineered agricultural seed have been confronted by freezes on the approval process for Bt transgenic corn by the European Commission and by "possible trade restrictions by Japan." In the United States, there have been calls for a moratorium on the further planting of Bt-corn.

In discussing the Cornell monarch butterfly report, Shelton and Roush voice their surprise that a "previous and more relevant and realistic study has been largely overlooked." While the Cornell laboratory study showed high mortality among monarch larvae that ingested genetically engineered pollen, an Iowa State University study by Laura Hansen and John Obrycki showed low mortality even when Monarch larvae were fed milkweed that had the highest levels of Bt pollen that would be encountered in the field. Shelton and Roush note that it is unlikely that these high Bt pollen levels would be encountered by the insects in the field, and they say that "few entomologists or weed scientists familiar with the butterflies or corn production give credence to the Nature article."

Crops are genetically engineered with Bt to control pests without the use of broad spectrum insecticides, which may cause environmental and human health problems. For example, the European corn borer is the most notorious pest that corn farmers face and causes an estimated $1.2 billion in crop losses annually. To combat this pest, an estimated 24 to 28 million acres of Bt-corn were planted in the United States in 1999.

Related World Wide Web sites: The following sites provide additional information on this news release. Some might not be part of the Cornell University community, and Cornell has no control over their content or availability.

-- Cornell News Service release on the Losey study:http://www.news.cornell.edu/releases/May99/Butterflies.bpf.html

-- The Hansen/Obrycki study:http://www.ent.iastate.edu/entsoc/ncb99/prog/abs/D81.html


Story Source:

The above story is based on materials provided by Cornell University. Note: Materials may be edited for content and length.


Cite This Page:

Cornell University. "Two Leading Researchers Take Issue With Three Recent Studies On The Effects Of Genetically Engineered Crops." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 13 September 1999. <www.sciencedaily.com/releases/1999/09/990913070602.htm>.
Cornell University. (1999, September 13). Two Leading Researchers Take Issue With Three Recent Studies On The Effects Of Genetically Engineered Crops. ScienceDaily. Retrieved September 3, 2014 from www.sciencedaily.com/releases/1999/09/990913070602.htm
Cornell University. "Two Leading Researchers Take Issue With Three Recent Studies On The Effects Of Genetically Engineered Crops." ScienceDaily. www.sciencedaily.com/releases/1999/09/990913070602.htm (accessed September 3, 2014).

Share This



More Plants & Animals News

Wednesday, September 3, 2014

Featured Research

from universities, journals, and other organizations


Featured Videos

from AP, Reuters, AFP, and other news services

Snack Attack: Study Says Action Movies Make You Snack More

Snack Attack: Study Says Action Movies Make You Snack More

Newsy (Sep. 2, 2014) You're more likely to gain weight while watching action flicks than you are watching other types of programming, says a new study published in JAMA. Video provided by Newsy
Powered by NewsLook.com
Get A Mortgage, Receive A Cat — Only In Russia

Get A Mortgage, Receive A Cat — Only In Russia

Newsy (Sep. 2, 2014) The incentive is in keeping with a Russian superstition that it's good luck for a cat to be the first to cross the threshold of a new home. Video provided by Newsy
Powered by NewsLook.com
U.N. Says Ebola Travel Restrictions Will Cause Food Shortage

U.N. Says Ebola Travel Restrictions Will Cause Food Shortage

Newsy (Sep. 2, 2014) The U.N. says the problem is two-fold — quarantine zones and travel restrictions are limiting the movement of both people and food. Video provided by Newsy
Powered by NewsLook.com
Sharks Off the Menu and on the Tourist Trail in Palau

Sharks Off the Menu and on the Tourist Trail in Palau

AFP (Sep. 2, 2014) Tourists in Palau clamour to dive with sharks thanks to a pioneering conservation initiative -- as the island nation plans to completely ban commercial fishing in its vast ocean territory. 01:15 Video provided by AFP
Powered by NewsLook.com

Search ScienceDaily

Number of stories in archives: 140,361

Find with keyword(s):
Enter a keyword or phrase to search ScienceDaily for related topics and research stories.

Save/Print:
Share:

Breaking News:
from the past week

In Other News

... from NewsDaily.com

Science News

Health News

Environment News

Technology News



Save/Print:
Share:

Free Subscriptions


Get the latest science news with ScienceDaily's free email newsletters, updated daily and weekly. Or view hourly updated newsfeeds in your RSS reader:

Get Social & Mobile


Keep up to date with the latest news from ScienceDaily via social networks and mobile apps:

Have Feedback?


Tell us what you think of ScienceDaily -- we welcome both positive and negative comments. Have any problems using the site? Questions?
Mobile: iPhone Android Web
Follow: Facebook Twitter Google+
Subscribe: RSS Feeds Email Newsletters
Latest Headlines Health & Medicine Mind & Brain Space & Time Matter & Energy Computers & Math Plants & Animals Earth & Climate Fossils & Ruins