NEW: Find great deals on the latest gadgets and more in the ScienceDaily Store!
Science News
from research organizations

Mycobacteria get all the advantages of sex with none of the downsides

July 10, 2013
Public Library of Science
Sexual reproduction is costly to organisms that depend on it, like humans. In contrast, bacteria reproduce by asexual reproduction, which is more efficient but doesn't allow genomic mixing, making them vulnerable to environmental change. A new report describes a process by which mycobacteria gain the best of both worlds, mixing their genomes as thoroughly as sexual organisms do, while retaining the advantages of asexual reproduction.

Sexual reproduction is costly to those organisms that depend on it, like humans. For starters, only half of the population can bear offspring and the other half has to work hard to make sure they're included in the future gene pool. The payoff is that sexual reproduction allows the mixing of parental genomes to generate potentially beneficial new combinations of gene variants that had not previously coexisted on the same strand of DNA, or to separate beneficial mutations from detrimental ones.

In contrast, bacteria reproduce by asexual reproduction -- this is more efficient than sexual reproduction since each individual can reproduce when it's ready, simply by dividing. However, the downside comes when the inevitable accumulation of mutations takes its toll, or changes to the environment make gene combinations less well suited than they had once been. Without an exchange mechanism like that provided by sexual reproduction, the bacteria and their offspring are stuck with the same set of genes, for better or for worse.

However, a new report published July 9 in the open access journal PLOS Biology describes a process by which bacteria can have the best of both worlds. Using a bacterial species related to the bacterium that causes tuberculosis, Keith Derbyshire, Todd Gray and colleagues, from the Wadsworth Centre in New York, show that a multitude of DNA fragments are simultaneously transferred from a donor bacterial strain to a recipient strain to create new strains that are genetic blends of the parents. The newly-described process, called Distributive Conjugal Transfer, creates patchwork genomes that are different from either parent and different from any siblings. This generates a degree of genome-wide variation similar to that generated in sexual reproduction.

If the new combination of gene variants make the offspring better suited for growth in its current environment, that bacterium will rapidly divide asexually, outcompete its parental (or sibling) strains and become established as an emerging strain or species in its own right.

Mechanisms by which DNA can be transferred between bacterial genomes have previously been described, but these have been piecemeal, limiting the potential evolutionary benefit, and requiring successive rounds of transfer to create a genome-wide mosaic. However, Distributive Conjugal Transfer generates mosaic genomes overnight. Thus, scientists may have to re-evaluate the projected time it might take for a new mycobacterial strain to evolve, suggest the authors.

The team also exploited a genomic mapping approach similar to those applied in sexually reproducing organisms to localize the mycobacterial genes that determine mating identity. Of the nearly 7,000 genes in the mycobacterial genome, one region spanning just 6 genes appears to be key in determining whether a mycobacterial strain will be a donor or recipient when it comes to mating. This information may help to predict which other bacterial species might participate in this form of gene transfer, and to identify just how widespread the phenomenon is.

The new study suggests that through Distributive Conjugal Transfer, mycobacteria have found a way to reap the benefits of genomic mixing without the dependence and energy costs associated with sexual reproduction. The findings may also shed light on the origin of related mycobacteria that cause tuberculosis. As more mycobacterial genomes are sequenced, a picture is emerging that Distributive Conjugal Transfer may have shuffled the genomes of environmental mycobacteria to create a strain that was particularly well suited for growth in mammalian lungs. However, whether pathogenic mycobacteria, or other non-pathogenic bacteria, actively participate in Distributive Conjugal Transfer has not yet been addressed.

Story Source:

Materials provided by Public Library of Science. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Journal Reference:

  1. Todd A. Gray, Janet A. Krywy, Jessica Harold, Michael J. Palumbo, Keith M. Derbyshire. Distributive Conjugal Transfer in Mycobacteria Generates Progeny with Meiotic-Like Genome-Wide Mosaicism, Allowing Mapping of a Mating Identity Locus. PLoS Biology, 2013; 11 (7): e1001602 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.1001602

Cite This Page:

Public Library of Science. "Mycobacteria get all the advantages of sex with none of the downsides." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 10 July 2013. <>.
Public Library of Science. (2013, July 10). Mycobacteria get all the advantages of sex with none of the downsides. ScienceDaily. Retrieved September 29, 2016 from
Public Library of Science. "Mycobacteria get all the advantages of sex with none of the downsides." ScienceDaily. (accessed September 29, 2016).