Science News
from research organizations

Supermassive black holes do not form from stellar black holes

April 6, 2016
University of Kentucky
Astrophysicists have revealed details of how supermassive black holes formed 13 billion years ago, and it's not from normal (stellar size) black holes growing to supermassive proportions.

Slices of collapsing gas within dark matter halos on three different spacial scales: from 10,0000 to 10 light years across. The colors represent the gas density, from low density (blue color) to much larger density (red color). The gas on the smallest spatial scales is going to form a supermassive black hole.
Credit: Isaac Shlosman, University of Kentucky

Often containing more than a billion times the mass than our Sun, supermassive black holes have perplexed humans for decades. But new research by University of Kentucky astrophysicist Isaac Shlosman and collaborators will help to understand the physical processes at the edge of time and space, providing the details of how supermassive black holes formed 13 billion years ago.

Shlosman, as well as Jun-Hwan Choi at the University of Texas at Austin, Mitchell Begelman at the University of Colorado- Boulder, and Kentaro Nagamine at Osaka University (Japan), ran simulations where supermassive black holes are seeded by clouds of gas falling into potential wells of dark matter -- the invisible matter that astronomers believe makes up 85 percent of the mass in the Universe.

The researchers found that while most seed particles in their simulations did not grow very much, one central seed grew rapidly to more than two million time the mass of our Sun in just two million years, demonstrating a feasible path toward a supermassive black hole.

"Of course pointing for a feasible path does not mean yet that we went all the way and formed such a bizarre object," said Shlosman, who is a professor in the UK Department of Physics and Astronomy. "Much more work is required. In a way this is a collective effort."

Dark matter dominates gravity in the universe and forms structures; as the universe expands, the dark matter clumps together and cannot cool down, forming dark matter wells, he explained.

"Clouds of gas can fall into the potential wells of dark matter and collapse, forming supermassive black holes," he said. "There are many obstacles on this way."

It was previously assumed by many that supermassive black holes were simply normal, or stellar, black holes that grew over time, but newly discovered quasars -- bright and distant objects which contain supermassive black holes, make this option less likely. Some of the distant quasars observed recently already existed 700 million years after the Big Bang. It would be very difficult to grow supermassive black holes from stellar size black holes in such a short time after the Big Bang.

An additional argument that supermassive black holes were seeded by the collapse of some of the first stars has also been debunked as "we have learned that those first stars were rather of normal size and collapsed into normal black holes," Shlosman said.

"Normal black holes and supermassive black holes are completely different beasts," he said.

Indeed, the simulations produced by supercomputers at UK and Osaka University plausibly show that supermassive black holes form by a completely different process than normal (stellar) black holes. The researchers expect their simulations to be validated when NASA's James Webb Space Telescope, due to be launched in 2018, observes distant sources where direct gas collapse is happening.

"We're at the forefront, but many questions remain," Shlosman said. "But the public and their curiosity deserve to have those answers; we cannot exclude anything if we want to keep advancing."

Story Source:

Materials provided by University of Kentucky. Original written by Whitney Harder. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.

Journal Reference:

  1. Isaac Shlosman, Jun-Hwan Choi, Mitchell C. Begelman, Kentaro Nagamine. Supermassive black hole seed formation at high redshifts: long-term evolution of the direct collapse. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 2015; 456 (1): 500 DOI: 10.1093/mnras/stv2700

Cite This Page:

University of Kentucky. "Supermassive black holes do not form from stellar black holes." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 6 April 2016. <>.
University of Kentucky. (2016, April 6). Supermassive black holes do not form from stellar black holes. ScienceDaily. Retrieved May 26, 2017 from
University of Kentucky. "Supermassive black holes do not form from stellar black holes." ScienceDaily. (accessed May 26, 2017).