RICHLAND, Wash. -- While several studies have focused on how estrogen from contraceptives may alter sex organs of juvenile fish, few studies have analyzed how exposure to estrogen affects adult fish as they make their way through rivers, lakes and streams to spawn. Now, a study by scientists at the Department of Energy's Pacific Northwest National Laboratory suggests that when adult male fish are exposed to short-term and low concentrations of a synthetic estrogen, their fertility can drop by as much as 50 percent.
The study, conducted with the University of Idaho, appears in the June issue of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry. Previous research reported that high concentrations of estrogen could change sex organs, causing juvenile male fish to develop female organs. Estrogen is an active ingredient in most oral contraceptives and often finds it way into surface waters through sewer systems. The PNNL study looked at the impact of a synthetic estrogen called ethynylestradiol, which is the chemical in oral contraceptives.
Irvin Schultz, PNNL toxicologist who led the study, said the research reinforces that impacts aren't limited to juvenile fish. "We can see that adult fish aren't immune to the effects of estrogen in waterways. Even short-term exposure to low levels of synthetic estrogen can impact their fertility," Schultz noted. "Our results indicate that the fertility of a healthy male trout that has developed normally still can be affected, if that exposure takes place during a critical sexual maturation stage before spawning."
In a controlled laboratory experiment, PNNL scientists from the lab's Marine Sciences Laboratory in Sequim, Wash., exposed adult male rainbow trout for 62 days to three different concentrations of ethynylestradiol -- 10, 100 and 1,000 nanograms per liter of water. The sperm of exposed fish were harvested then used in a controlled in-vitro fertilization process with eggs from a healthy female rainbow trout. After 28 days, a measurable decrease in fertilization was observed in the treated trout compared with a control group. In some experiments, a 50 percent decrease in sperm fertilization capacity was noted in semen collected from the trout exposed to 10 nanograms of ethynylestradiol per liter. For example, in an experiment using 50,000 sperm for one egg, the exposed fish had 22 percent fertilization compared with 45 percent fertilization of control fish.
That impact is important, say researchers, because 10 nanograms per liter is a level found in some surface water samples. Schultz and his colleagues, including co-author Jim Nagler of the University of Idaho, studied the possible mechanisms for reduced fertility, specifically sperm motility and decreased hormone levels. While they were able to rule out sperm motility as the mechanism, their research revealed increased -- not decreased -- hormone levels in the blood plasma of fish exposed to 10 nanograms per liter of ethynylestradiol. But hormone levels did decrease in fish exposed to the larger concentration of 100 nanograms of ethynylestradiol.
"While other research has shown the visible change that can take place when young male fish are exposed to high levels of estrogen, we're suggesting that low and short-term exposure can have just as significant -- but not physically observable -- effects," Schultz said.
Business inquiries on this or other areas of research at PNNL should be directed to 888-375-PNNL or [email protected]. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory is a DOE Office of Science research facility and delivers breakthrough science and technology in the areas of environment, energy, health, fundamental sciences and national security. Battelle, based in Columbus, Ohio, has operated the laboratory for DOE since 1965.
Cite This Page: